Research Cell: Editorial Policy
The Editorial Policy of Bacha Khan Dental College (BKDC) is primarily reflected in the detailed guidelines and ethical standards of its official publication, the Journal of Bacha Khan Medical College (JBKMC). This policy is designed to ensure the integrity, quality, and ethical conduct of all published research, aligning with best practices in scholarly publishing.
Here's a comprehensive breakdown of JBKMC's Editorial Policy, drawing from their "Editorial and Publication Policy" and related sections on their website:
I. Journal's Scope and Vision:
· Mission: JBKMC is dedicated to advancing medical knowledge by publishing high-quality, original research articles, reviews, case reports, and commentaries in all fields of medicine and allied health sciences.1
· Target Audience: Its readership includes faculty, clinicians, postgraduate trainees, and researchers in various health disciplines both nationally and internationally.
· Commitment: The journal aims to provide a reputable platform for the dissemination of scientific knowledge and supports open scientific dialogue and academic excellence.2
II. Editorial Independence and Authority:
· Independence: Editorial decisions are made independently by the Editorial Board without any influence from the institution (BKMC), sponsors, or any other external entities.
· Final Authority: The Editor-in-Chief holds the final authority over the content published in the journal.
III. Peer Review Process:
· Double-Blind Peer Review: JBKMC employs a rigorous double-blind peer review process. This means the identities of both the authors and the reviewers are kept confidential throughout the review process to maintain objectivity and prevent bias.
· Initial Screening: Submitted manuscripts are initially screened by the editorial team to check for adherence to submission guidelines, scope, and basic quality. Manuscripts that do not comply are returned to authors without review.
· Reviewer Selection: Manuscripts are assigned to at least two independent experts in the relevant field based on their expertise, academic background, and previous research publications.
· Reviewer Responsibilities: Reviewers are expected to:
o Evaluate the manuscript objectively, fairly, and within the given timeframe (typically 2-3 weeks).
o Maintain strict confidentiality of the manuscript's content.
o Provide constructive and clear feedback with a recommendation (accept, revise, or reject).
o Declare any conflicts of interest.
· Confidentiality: Manuscripts under review are confidential documents3 and must not be discussed or shared with anyone without permission from the editorial office.
IV. Ethical Standards and Publication Ethics:
JBKMC adheres to the highest ethical standards in research and publication, strictly following the recommendations of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) and the ethical publishing standards set by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Key ethical principles include:
· Originality and Plagiarism:
o Authors must certify that their manuscripts are their original work.
o Plagiarism in all its forms4 (verbatim, paraphrasing, self-plagiarism) is unacceptable.
o All submitted manuscripts are checked for similarity using Turnitin.
o Specific similarity index thresholds (e.g., <19% acceptable, 19-30% for revision, >30% for rejection, as detailed in the Plagiarism Policy).
o Cases of plagiarism, fabrication, or falsification of data will result in rejection and may lead to further action (e.g., retraction of published articles, notification to institutions, debarment).
· Authorship and Contributorship:
o Authorship is based on the ICMJE's four criteria:
1. Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work; or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation5 of data for the work;6 AND
2. Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content; AND
3. Final approval of the version to be published; AND
4. Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.7
o All authors must meet all four criteria.8
o Contributors who do not meet all criteria should be acknowledged in the "Acknowledgements" section.
o Authors are required to provide a contributions statement defining each author's specific role.
o The journal generally does not permit changes (additions or deletions) to the author list after initial submission.
o Policies for handling deceased authors are also specified.
· Conflict of Interest (COI):
o All authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose any potential conflicts of interest (financial, personal, or professional) that could influence the9 manuscript's evaluation or publication.
o A COI Disclosure Statement will be published in all articles.
· Ethical Research Involving Humans and Animals:
o Strict adherence to the Declaration of Helsinki and ICMJE recommendations for human research.
o All studies involving human participants must include a statement confirming ethical approval from an appropriate IRB/Ethics Committee (with name and approval number).
o Confirmation of informed consent from participants (or legal guardians) is mandatory. Explicit consent for publication must be obtained if identifiable patient images or information are used.
o Animal experiments must comply with ARRIVE guidelines and internationally accepted principles for the care and use of laboratory animals, including ethical approval details.
· Data Access and Retention: Authors may be asked to provide raw data for editorial review and should be prepared to provide public access to such data if practicable.
V. Manuscript Submission and Formatting:
· Online Submission: Manuscripts must be submitted electronically via the journal's Online Journal System (OJS).
· Author Guidelines: Strict adherence to the journal's guidelines regarding format, structure, word limits, reference style (Vancouver), and ethical standards. Manuscripts not complying may be returned.
· Originality Declaration: Authors must confirm that the manuscript is original and has not been published or submitted elsewhere concurrently.
VI. Corrections, Retractions, and Appeals:
· Corrections: The journal is committed to correcting errors. Minor errors will result in corrections (errata).
· Retractions: Retractions or expressions of concern will be issued for significant issues such as ethical breaches (e.g., major plagiarism, data fabrication) or major errors that compromise the scientific validity of the published work. These actions are taken in accordance with COPE guidelines.
· Appeals and Complaints: Authors can appeal editorial decisions or submit complaints in writing to the Editor-in-Chief. Appeals are reviewed by an independent committee, and a final decision is communicated. The journal has a transparent process for investigating complaints related to ethical misconduct, bias, or delays.
VII. Open Access and Copyright:
· Open Access: JBKMC is an open-access journal, providing free and immediate access to its content to facilitate wide dissemination of research findings.
· Licensing: Articles are published under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0), allowing unrestricted use, distribution, adaptation, and reproduction, provided appropriate credit is given.
· Copyright: Authors retain the copyright of their work while granting the journal a license to publish.
VIII. Article Processing Charges (APC):
· JBKMC charges Article Processing Charges (APCs) upon acceptance of the article by the editorial board and peer review. These charges vary for faculty members/consultants and trainee medical officers/house officers.
· BKMC partially covers publication costs to enable the journal to operate as an open-access publication.
In summary, the Editorial Policy of JBKMC, and by extension, Bacha Khan Medical College's approach to publishing, is built on pillars of rigorous peer review, unwavering ethical standards, transparency, and a commitment to open access dissemination of high-quality medical research.